bohemianwanderer – Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches have made a highly anticipated comeback at Costco, just in time for summer. Last year, their Cookie Monster flavor sold out within a week, becoming an instant favorite among ice cream lovers. Now, the brand introduces a refreshing Strawberry Shortcake flavor, combining creamy strawberry ice cream with chewy brown sugar cookies. This new flavor promises the same quality and rich taste that Nightingale fans expect. Available exclusively in Costco’s Northeast stores, the strawberry sandwiches come in convenient 18-packs, perfect for sharing or enjoying throughout the warm season.
What Makes Nightingale Sandwiches Stand Out
Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches stand out because of their handcrafted quality and delicious ingredients. They use 14% butterfat ice cream, which creates a rich and creamy texture. Their cookies are freshly baked and chewy, complementing the perfectly. The Strawberry Shortcake flavor features fresh, fruit-forward notes with quality mix-ins, like real berries, making it ideal for summer. Unlike other larger Nightingale sandwiches found in stores, these “chomp-sized” treats come in larger Costco-exclusive packs, offering great value and portion control. This combination of taste, texture, and size keeps customers coming back for more.
Availability and Regional Exclusivity at Costco
Currently, Nightingale’s new Strawberry Shortcake ice cream sandwiches are only available at Costco stores in the Northeast region. This includes over 132 locations spanning from Virginia to Maine. The brand actively encourages fans to petition Costco for wider distribution through social media. Customers across the country can help by tagging their local Costco stores, urging them to carry these popular ice cream sandwiches. While the 18-packs remain exclusive to Costco in the Northeast, four-packs of Nightingale sandwiches may be found at other retailers nationwide.
Pricing and Value Compared to Other Retailers
Each 18-pack box of Nightingale’s Strawberry Shortcake ice cream sandwiches sells for approximately $19.99 at Costco, depending on location. This breaks down to about $1.11 per sandwich, making it an affordable bulk purchase. In contrast, other retailers usually offer Nightingale sandwiches in four-packs priced between $7 and $9, which can cost significantly more per piece. This pricing difference makes Costco the best option for stocking up on these tasty treats. Customers looking for a convenient, cost-effective way to enjoy quality ice cream sandwiches should consider this bulk deal.
Explore Other Nightingale Flavors and Where to Buy
Besides Strawberry Shortcake and Cookie Monster, Nightingale offers a variety of creative flavors. Options like Miso Churro, Banana Pudding, Key Lime Pie, and Chocolate French Toast showcase the brand’s innovation and passion for unique taste experiences. The Nightingale website helps customers locate nearby retailers carrying these flavors and provides detailed product information. For fans of artisan ice cream sandwiches, the wide flavor range and availability at select stores present an exciting opportunity to try new favorites. Those interested in seasonal fruit-forward desserts should act fast to grab the exclusive Costco packs before they sell out.
